Fay, who had been living in Singapore since 1992, was arrested and charged in early October 1993 for possession of stolen items, including Singapore state flags, road signs and various other signboards. Later that month, he was also charged with vandalising a number of cars and committing several acts of mischief, including spray-painting the cars and throwing eggs at some of them. In total, he was charged with 45 counts of vandalism, six counts of mischief, one count of retaining stolen items and one count of possessing firecrackers - 53 charges in all.
On 28 February 1994, he pleaded guilty in the district court to two counts of vandalism, two counts of mischief and one count of possessing stolen property. Besides these five charges, 16 other counts of vandalism and four other counts of mischief were also taken into consideration. On 3 March, he was sentenced to four months' jail and six strokes of the cane for the two vandalism charges and fined S$3,500 for the other three charges. He was acquitted of the remaining 28 charges.





